At nearly 2:30 a.m., Nov. 8, detectives with the sheriff’s office executed a search warrant on a local motel in Murphy that resulted in the seizure of illegal narcotic and paraphernalia, including methamphetamine, marijuana, opioid pills, and heroin, according to a statement from Sheriff Derrick Palmer.
The search warrant was issued after the sheriff’s office received information Nov. 7 that Benjamin Highsmith was renting a room at the motel and was selling illegal drugs from the location.
Detectives conducted surveillance on the room and made several traffic stops on individuals that visited the room.
As a result of the traffic stops, detectives recovered approximately 3.41 grams of grey powder heroin, 4.02 grams of black tar heroin, .21 grams of methamphetamine, and assorted prescriptions pills that are controlled substances under the North Carolina Controlled Substance Act, according to Palmer’s statement.
When detectives attempted to gain access the room, Highsmith was able to flush an unknown amount of drugs and cash down the toilet, according to the statement.
Despite that, officers were able to seize approximately 140 grams (5 ounces) of Black Tar Heroin. Officers were also able to seize a small amount of prescription pills, $845 in cash, and a semi-automatic handgun.
The Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office received assistance from the Cherokee Tribal Police and the Murphy Police Department.
Those charged in the investigation were:
-Jessie Crist, age 38, of Murphy, who was arrested and charged with possession of methamphetamine and possession of drug paraphernalia;
-Louis Tarantino Jr., age 38, of Murphy, who was arrested and charged with simple possession of Schedule V and possession of drug paraphernalia;
-Benjamin Highsmith, age 29, of Rome, Georgia, who was arrested and charged with trafficking in heroin, possession with intent to sell and deliver heroin, simple possession of Schedule II controlled substance, possession of drug paraphernalia, and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon; and,
To report suspicious activities and suspected violations of the law, concerned citizens can call 828-837-1344 or submit a tip at crime.tips@cherokeecounty-nc.gov.
CHEROKEE COUNTY, NC — On August 27, 2026, the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office was notified…
Arrest report with photos provided by the Cherokee County NC Sheriff’s Office without images. Pursuant to…
Arrest report with photos provided by the Cherokee County NC Sheriff’s Office without images. Pursuant to…
Murphy picked up a big rivalry win Tuesday night, taking down Robbinsville 3-1 on the…
CHEROKEE COUNTY, NC — The Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office is announcing arrests in connection with…
2026 SMC Preview PRESEASON RANKINGS 1. Murphy 2. Robbinsville …