Categories: BREAKING NEWS

Murder in Murphy NC has a “No-Change” verdict on Day 3 deliberations

John Anthony Hill 

The jury has been in deliberations since Monday at approximately 3:15 p.m. after hearing about the evidence surrounding a murder committed in Murphy, NC in 2014. Today, at the close of court, the jury came back with a “No-Change” verdict against John Anthony Hill. Hill’s trial has been in session for nearly three weeks

Hill was accused of murdering “his best friend of five years”, Paul George Pfleiderer, Jr., age 57, a resident of the Peachtree community in Murphy.

Cherokee County Sheriff’s Department arrested Hill for the murder of Pfleiderer on June 29, 2014. Hill has been in custody at the Cherokee County Detention Center since.

Paul George Pfleiderer

Pfleiderer passed away on Sunday, June 29, 2014, after sustaining massive blows to his head. Allegedly, Hill stated he gave as many as six blows to Pfleiderer’s head with an an aluminum baseball bat following a brief struggle at Hill’s home.

The jury deliberations center around what verdict to return against Hill.

Court will reconvene 9:30 a.m. Thursday morning in the Cherokee County Courthouse located at 33 Peachtree Street in Murphy.

More details will become available when the verdict is reached.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

FetchYourNews.com attracts more than 300,000 page views and 3.5 million impressions per month for ad server. FYNTV attracts approximately 15,000 to 60,000 per week Facebook page reach. For the most effective, least expensive local advertising, call 706-276-6397 or visit advertise@FetchYourNews.com

Maria Kidder

View Comments

  • I think John Anthony Hill should be given the death penalty , he took a life so he should have to give a life ! Paul was a friend of mine and a very good person. IDK How many different Very Bad things I could tell you about " Tony " Hill in short he is just not a good person!!!

Share
Published by
Maria Kidder
Tags: Murphy NC

Recent Posts

Murphy Grinds Out Home Win

Bulldogs Gut Out 21-17 Win Over A.C. Reynolds MURPHY — This one felt like Murphy…

5 hours ago

Cherokee County, NC Sheriff’s Office Arrest Report 8/30 – 9/5/2026

Arrest report with photos provided by the Cherokee County NC Sheriff’s Office without images.  Pursuant to…

2 days ago

Deputy Struck by ATV During Pursuit

CHEROKEE COUNTY, NC — On August 27, 2026, the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office was notified…

2 weeks ago

Cherokee County, NC Sheriff’s Office Arrest Report 8/16 – 8/22/2026

Arrest report with photos provided by the Cherokee County NC Sheriff’s Office without images.  Pursuant to…

3 weeks ago

Cherokee County, NC Sheriff’s Office Arrest Report 8/1 – 8/16/2026

Arrest report with photos provided by the Cherokee County NC Sheriff’s Office without images.  Pursuant to…

4 weeks ago

Murphy Volleyball Defeats Robbinsville 3-1

Murphy picked up a big rivalry win Tuesday night, taking down Robbinsville 3-1 on the…

4 weeks ago